Comfortably Numb

Sheila Kumar's Storehouse

Published on: 06/20/21 4:24 AM

Book review: Writing the City, edited by Stuti Khanna

Depicted as experienced

 This slim volume contains literary essays that artfully entwine the perfectly compatible strands of travel and personal memoir to good effect. A list of known names write about the cities they have situated their works in, the cities of their imagination versus the reality, the cities that strike a creative chord in them.

The selected cities range from the capital of the country to Calcutta, Patna, Shillong, Bombay, Gaya, Bangalore, Amritsar, Siliguri, a short leap away to  Kathmandu, then a longer leap all the way to Baltimore. These are intensely personal and unabashedly subjective depictions, and need to be read as such; the nuggets contained therein are mined from the essayist’s lived or imagined experiences.

Editor Stuti Khanna talks of Georg Simmel, Dickens, Marquez, Rushdie, Aravind Adiga, Ratika Kapur and their ilk, writers who have settled their  stories of much poignancy/ joy/ sorrow/ wit,  in cities that sometimes though not always,  took on a life of their own under the pen of these gifted flaneurs; how the cities imbue the writing with a certain richness and vitality, a slow coil of energy that lies dormant when it must, springs to startling life when it must.

All the pieces are resonant pieces of writing but some just happen to resonate more than the others, leave the reader with things to muse on. And so you have Chandrahas Choudhury providing  an interesting perspective on Delhi and Bombay, opining that he fed off the distance and perspective on Bombay provided by Delhi, seeing both cities as stable poles in his world. Bombay, he says is the presiding deity of his imagination, a place where he hears the hidden notes of life. Delhi for its part, lets him experience the charm and propulsive force of another set of values.

Manju Kapur`s canvas is a broader one but her point is that no matter where she travelled abroad, she was always the outsider; within the country,  however,  she is immersed in it in a way that goes down to her bones. If writers have to perfect the art of persuasion, they need to convince themselves before they can convince anybody else, and India, does that for her.

Anita Nair`s piece takes the reader to one of Bangalore`s most colourful areas, the Ramzan night market in Shivajinagar, and a work trip for her next novel opens up a world soaked in colour, sound and smell for us.

Saikat Majumdar, terming himself an ethnographer of memory not of reality, asserts  that writing about a place of memory always half-remembered never fully, becomes an exercise separated by time and space,  as also by a certain kind of awareness and sensibility.

Cyrus Mistry keeps referencing his famous brother Rohinton in his piece, where he writes  of the political city. He makes an ironical point when he says  that several of Rohinton`s works are all set in a Bombay of long ago, not in Canada, where the author has lived for many decades now.

Zac O`Yeah  casts a sardonically witty eye on his city of residence,  Bangalore, stating firmly that every self-respecting metropolis needs its own detective novel series. The writer who gave Beantown its own home-grown gumshoe, Hari Majestic, tells us how he wandered the streets of the Majestic area, taking in sights, sounds, smells and of course the people too, all of which became eventual grist to his creative mill. O`Yeah ends on a note of pure whimsy when he avers that writing books is a little similar to staying alive in Bengaluru, basically a chaotic activity.

Heading to what is known as a B town, Siddharth Chowdhury declares that his aim is to write Patna stories that are accessible everywhere, provincial in setting but never in tone, realistic in flight but majestic in their dying fall. Tabish Khair sings a paean to Gaya `pickled in provincialism` but holding many complex realities just below its surface. Sumana Roy takes us to Siliguri and writes about her home there, giving us a clear picture of a house, a neighbourhood, a state of being, a remembrance of things past and present.

As for Anees Salim, it took him years of escaping to the cities to turn his gaze inwards, homewards. He duly takes us on an evocative walk through his  hometown, an unnamed town in Kerala.

Samrat Upadhyay takes  Salman Rushdie`s statement  that for the émigré writer, it’s the lack of proximity both in time and space which generates the fictiveness and tweaks it, suggesting  that proximity doesn’t guarantee realness, either, glazed as it is by the experiences of the beholder.

The book is an interesting look at the inner and outer landscape of a writer.

 Writing the City, Looking Within, Looking Without. Edited by Stuti Khanna. Orient Black Swan. Rs 750. 120 pages.

This appeared in the Sunday Herald of 20 June 2021.

Related Links:

Book review: Askew, a Short Biography of Bangalore by TJS George


Anees SalimAnita NairChandrahas Choudhurycities of Indiacities of the imaginationcities that existCyrus Mistryedited by Stuti KhannaManju KapurmemoirOrient Black Swan BooksSaikat MajumdarSamrat UpadhyaySiddharth ChowdhurytravelogueWriting the CityZac O`Yeah

Sheila Kumar • June 20, 2021

Previous Post

Next Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published / Required fields are marked *